Comments on this article
|
fh athlete
01-22-2001 5:06 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
i know exactly what you mean. always a struggle - field hockey or my obsession to be skinny.
|
|
Also a div. 1 athlete
01-22-2001 8:01 pm
|
Report this post
|
I think your story is one that any competitave female athlete can sympathize with.
thank you for sharing it. now i know I'm not alone!
|
|
Heidi
01-23-2001 12:08 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
It very nice to hear an atheltic say this kind of thing.
|
|
Wendy Brady
01-23-2001 1:27 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Excellent article! I also played DI hockey and also attest to the paradox sometimes faced by women athletes: strong or slim! I'm writing my MA thesis on this very subject and welcome anyone else's comments on this issue: wmbrady22@aol.com. I think it's important for female athletes to recognize the damaging mixed messages sent by the media, coaches and teammates about body image and athletics -- why, suddenly, are so many great athletes posing nude to make money? Why not let athleticism stand alone instead of touting sexuality along with it? Thanks for a great, honest look at the problem, Jessica.
|
|
Annabel Griffiths
01-23-2001 3:17 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Thanks for such an honest article. Many people assume that athletes are exempt from body image problems, so the more that it is kept out in the open,the better equipped we are to deal with it.
|
|
Also D-1 Athlete
01-23-2001 3:58 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I am a foreigner playing in America and this article exemplifies what is wrong with hockey in America. Only in America is there so much emphasis on fitness and not on skills that is why there national team struggles.
|
|
Sage
01-24-2001 10:18 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
This is only the begining of the story. Reed you wrote a great article. I lived through this so your happiness is what makes the journey worth while. As I always said what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. This has only made you a stronger person, inside. I know the hardnose Reed, but this shows me that you finally have that inner peace of mind that will get ride of the coal. (that I could only do in the past) I love you babe... all of you!!!
|
|
Julie King
01-25-2001 5:35 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I will certainly be using this article for younger players. I think that it becomes an obsession with some people. I think that coaches have a responsibility to ensure that players are SENSIBLE (man, I hate that word!) about weight, training etc.
|
|
Steve Jennings
01-27-2001 12:07 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I had several strong reactions to the article. As Jessica's coach for her senior year, I am proud of her accomplishments as an athlete, as a student and as a person. I admire her ability to talk openly about such a difficult issue and hope with all my heart that she remains happy with herself for who she is...a wonderful person. I would like to say that it is critical that as a society (particularly in America) we change the definition of terms like "beauty", of "health" of "fitness". Because what I see is a society that dooms all but half of one percent to feelings of failure. It is mutually exclusive to be a great athlete in a power sport like hockey and have a physical appearance like the cover girl of Cosmo. Among other problems, the majority of these "women" are under the age of 18, are made to look older than they are, often starve themselves, and are airbrushed, lighted, or made up to appear "flawless"...this is fantasy and it is damaging for people to accept it is reality or the defining standards for how you should look. Further, I think that one of the problems in America is a strong tendency for people to change their physical appearance in order to be happy or more desirable to others. This often leads people to diets/eating disorders. Most people have horrible advice on diets and are swept up by a staggering number of corporations that are trying to make millions of dollars off of low self-esteem and empty promises. I see many people that want a quick fix or a dramatic result instead of eating a sensible well-rounded diet and losing weight (if they are actually over-weight) over a longer period of time. It is critical for everyone to reject the way of thinking that others are forcing on us. In sport, our appearance will mimic what we do...and we should all be proud of that and recognize it for what it really is: beauty.
|
|
Ian Bird
01-27-2001 12:22 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Canadian National Karate Champion, Lisa Ling and amateur sport agent, Jane Roos are challenging us all to think about female athletes, self-esteem and beauty in different ways. Check out www.futureisfemale.com.
|
|
Lisa Ling
02-01-2001 1:21 pm
|
Report this post
|
Beauty and strength come from within. Let's celebrate that and change the idea of the "perfect woman" by creating alternative role models other than rake-thin models. Congratulations Jessica on dealing with this and sharing a difficult experience with us. I'm also in Washington DC. Let's talk. lisa@futureisfemale.com
www.futureisfemale.com
|
|
Sian
02-19-2001 11:31 am
|
Report this post
|
|
You may be interested to look at www.nordicnudes.com. The five members of the senior women's cross-country ski team made a calendar for profile and fundraising. Personally, I think it is great to see fit, athletic, muscular women comfortable in their own bodies - it hangs in our kitchen! But, I would be curious to hear others' opinions, given some of the opinions expressed above.
|
|
Al Mattei
03-02-2001 11:36 am
|
Report this post
|
An extraordinary story by an extraordinary woman, who I have known for the better part of a half-decade.
For most acquaintances of persons with body image problems, so much of their reaction was, "Gee, I didn't even know." That's how scary the problem of eating disorders is in American society; it is a hidden killer.
Few female athletes have come out about this: gymnast Kristie Phillips, UConn's Shea Ralph, and swimmer Dara Torres are ones who come to mind.
I congratulate Jessica for telling her story in the first person; I know at least one player from her era who has become a recluse after her battles with bulemia at an ACC school. Nobody knows where she is -- such is the secretive nature of an eating disorder.
With all the talk about women "self-empowering" themselves through boudoir photography (the Nordic Nudes, Brandi Chastain, Gabrielle Reece, Jenny Thompson, the Playboy Extreme Team, etc.), the image of the athletic woman is, unfortunately, being shaped by the same people shaping images in fashion. Thin -- really thin -- is in.
That, I think, is the real problem overall -- not necessarily in field hockey, where an overemphasis on fitness has tried to turn everybody into gazelle-like Vizzuso clones. Problem is, it just doesn't work that way!
In closing, Jess, I hope all is well with you; send me an email if you have a chance!
|
|
Nicole
03-08-2001 3:03 am
|
Report this post
|
I'm a previous State and Australian University field hockey player here in Australia. The same problem is happening over here with many of our young talented players being told that to make it to the top their body shape is just as important as their skills. I am also an umpire and find that this issue is also rife within the umpiring scene. As the game at a National level is televised, we are told that our image as umpires and players need to fit the "Cosmo image" so as to appeal to a wider audience.
The uniforms we wear have changed to be sleeker and sexier, rather than practical. For many female hockey players the uniforms they are forced to wear are in no way flattering if you are of a muscular build so the players are conscious of that. Why can't we change? Until the people in the magazine industry realise that we are all not reed thin and live off rabbit food - but are female athletes who need good nutrition and look good no matter what our shape we will be a poorer sport for it.
|
|
Canadian
03-13-2001 6:45 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
This is a great article. I know exactly what whe is talking about. I can't wait wait for the day when I fit back into my pants that I used to wear.
|
|
Kiwi
03-20-2001 11:27 am
|
Report this post
|
|
I really have to say that this article is so honest and it probally wasn't easy to write it. Not everyone could do that. That shows that Jessica's got her self-esteem back, otherwise she wouldn't be able to write her story down. I myself have had a weight problem, being 5'11" used to weigh about 170lbs. But now I have about 30lbs less, feeling much fitter than before. But I have to say that though I was never happy with my body shape, I was always with my life. And that's what helped me becoming physically fit again and even become happy with my body shape. It also lifted my self-esteem up. To al lthe girls out there: You can do it! But forst you have to get over that wanting-to-be-skinny-as-a-cosmo-cover-girl-thing! That just makes you sick and depressed and you'll never get the results that you want. Be sensible about every step you take and make YOU feel happy with yourself first before making other people with your body shape! Heads up!!!
|
|
liz former player, playing again soon
03-29-2001 10:58 am
|
Report this post
|
|
I can completely identify with Jessica. I too had similiar problems while playing university hockey. No matter what much I exercised the weight would not shed, then I started to "purge" everything I ate. That was another ungodly mess, it took years to rediscover my own body. I am now happy with what I look like, but still have constantly be careful of not attempting to "purge" food again.
|
|
Liz, former hockey player, returning soon
03-29-2001 11:19 am
|
Report this post
|
|
I fully understand the situation of Jessica, I too had a similair problem. I too am only 5'4", and weighed while playing university hockey approxiamatly the same as Jessica. I too became obsessed about losing weight, the majority of my teamates were "skinny", why wasn't I? I began to "purge" everything I ate, and when not doing that, I lived off juice, water, and popcorn. I looked great eventually; however, my energy levels were dangerously low. My grades also started to suffer, my relationship with family and friends also suffered. I now can finally say I am happy and content with my body image, although I still exercise and workout on a regular basis, I now love myself for me, and me alone.
|
|
|
|
Jeff, Age 53
04-08-2001 2:42 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
It is a shame that the guys fed back her insecurity about appearance, and their own for that matter. Physical strength in an athlete is a necessity. I have never understood why men did not admire that in women the way they did in men. I know I would have if I were her age.
|
|
Jessica Reed
04-18-2001 5:35 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Re: my email address is jreed@planetfieldhockey.com
|
|
gillian
06-01-2001 12:50 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
i think it is very brave of you to tell all about your struggles and brings hope to us all facing the same struggle.
|
|
Anne
07-18-2001 1:04 pm
|
Report this post
|
Great, great article. It is not often that we can really see inside what is forcing so many people to do this these days, and luckily it is when that person has overcome(so to speak)the majority of their problem. I, too, am a D1 athlete and will be for another 3 years. College life is hard, especially when athletics is such a major part of ones day. The repetetive talk of getting strong, faster - better...not only does this crush ones self esteem(if they are unable to fit into that mold)but it crushes all hope to ever become that way. Having now realized that if i want to continue playing i must deal with these issues reasonably i am more at ease with the idea. Though we all know that there is always that thought still in our heads, no matter how silent or uneffective it may be, it seems to always remain there.
I respect this article far more than any other, it will now and in the future help many student-athletes, athletes and girls in general,come to terms with their disorder.
|
|
Lizzie
09-01-2001 8:29 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Jess...You are a truly great person! I only wish all females--athletes or not--would absorb what you have said. It is so encouraging to see how many people have responded to this (Hi Sage!). I look forward to anything and everything else you have left to offer.
|
|
Visitation students (Mary, Teresa, KT)
09-28-2001 12:15 pm
|
Report this post
|
Jessica's Visit to Visitation Health class
Dear Jessica,
We thought that your talk was very informative and helpful. Now we know what to look out for if we are going to consider playing college sports. We also think that it was very courageous and brave of you to get up in front of a bunch of people and discuss your personal problems. We agree that if any of us had a problem like you did we wouldn't be able to openly discuss it with other people. You are an inspiration to all of us. YOU'RE AWESOME!!!
|
|
Kathleen and Maggie(from Visitation)
09-28-2001 12:21 pm
|
Report this post
|
Dear Jessica,
Thank you for informing us about the danger of eating disorders. We are grateful for your coming in and giving us your presentation. We thought it was very brave of you to openly talk about your disorder. Thanks again for your time and thanks for educating us about your struggle with this awful disease., It must have been very hard. Congratulations on over-coming it!
|
|
Visitation Health Class- Nancy, Kristen, Danielle
09-28-2001 1:15 pm
|
Report this post
|
our response to your talk
Wethink that your talk showed that you were a strong person for recognizing a problem you had and doing something about it. Your talk was informative because it taught us interesting facts about health and gave us important tips for maintaning good health
|
|
Amanda,Molly, and charlotte
09-28-2001 1:18 pm
|
Report this post
|
response to speech
Your speech was very informative especially because we never knew about that kind of anoerexia. You also taught us many valuable lessons. We especially admire your bravery for being able to get in front of the classes and admit everything. Thankyou.
|
|
Casey, Shannon, Kathleen, and Megan
09-28-2001 1:51 pm
|
Report this post
|
Thank You!
Thank you for coming to speak to us at Georgetown Visitation about anorexia athletica. We much apreciated your well given presentation on your problem. We have learned about anorexia before, but hearing about it from a first-hand experience, like yours, was very enlightening. Thank you again, and good luck in the future.
|
|
Magee and Brooke
09-28-2001 1:56 pm
|
Report this post
|
Thanks for the talk!
Thank you so much for coming to speak to the class. We really think that it has opened our eyes to different types of eating disorders. Usually girls only think about bulimia and anorexia. Aneroxia athletica really has a physchological side as much as a physical side. We're really trying to eat enough and healthily with playing sports and school.
|
|
Mary, Liz, Colleen, and Polly
09-28-2001 2:02 pm
|
Report this post
|
The girls from Visitation
Thank Jess for coming to talk to us here at Visitation. We were very interested to learn about Anorexia Athletica. You motivated us to pay more attention to our diets and our calorie intake, especially when we are being very active. Good luck with this season!
|
|
Ashley and Lauren fom Georgetown Visitation
10-02-2001 11:46 am
|
Report this post
|
Thank you Jessica!
Jessica, we would like to formally thank you for coming in to speak to our class. Your speech was inspirational as well as informative. It's scary how something like "herbal" laxatives can sound so healthy, but be used so wrongly. Because of your speech, we have decided to look out for possible bad health influences for ourselves, our family, and friends. Thank you once again for teaching us through your experiences!!
-Lauren and Ashley
|
|
Laurie Adamson and CLaire Rivero
10-02-2001 11:50 am
|
Report this post
|
Thanx Jessica
Jessica,
We want to thank you for coming in to talk with us. It made us realizze things we should be aware of if we plan to do a college sport. We appreciate your openess and honesty. We wish you sucess in your recovery.
|
|
Kara, Chelsea, Patricia, and Jill (Visitation Heal
10-02-2001 12:24 pm
|
Report this post
|
Thank you
Thank you so much for coming and talking to us about your health issue. It was very informative and we understand how hard it is for you to talk about it. We hope you recover fully and continue to live a happy and healthy life.
|
|
Allison, Ann, Megan, Katherine
10-02-2001 12:33 pm
|
Report this post
|
THANK YOU FOR COMING TO TALK WITH OUR CLASS
Thanks for ocming in to our class and telling us about your eating disorder. We really learned a lot about college athletes and weight issues. The information was great and it will help us in the future when we start playing sports at a larger level. We're gald your in remision and thanks again.
|
|
Tracy, Erin, LAUREN
10-02-2001 12:39 pm
|
Report this post
|
Thanks!
Dear Jess,
Thank you so much for coming and sharing your experience with us. We think you are a very strong person, and a good role model for overcoming your difficulties. We enjoyed your talk, and we learned a lot. Thanks Again!!!!
|
|
Ashley, Shelly, Miriam, and Stefany
10-02-2001 1:03 pm
|
Report this post
|
Dear Jessica,
Thank-you! You were very inspirational to us.Your talk helped us understand more about Anorexia Athletica. We did not know that you could be Anorexic and have unoticeable symptoms, nor did we know that Anorexia affected athletes. Good luck budy with field hockey this season! WIN! WIN! WIN!
Thank- you
|
|
Katherine, Maggie, Laurie, and Maria
10-02-2001 1:07 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Thank you so much for coming to talk to us. We thought it was great how you overcame your disorder. It must have taken a lot of personal strength both mentally and physically. We also feel that you have helped to teach us some healthy ways to eat healthy! Thanks again!
|
|
Jodi
10-15-2001 8:00 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I loved your article. I am only in 8th grade but I am soo crazy about hockey. I play on our Junior High team and mext year I am going to try out for High School. I wish to also play in college.
|
|
Jodi
10-15-2001 8:03 pm
|
Report this post
|
I play junior high feild hockey except I am having problems w/ my coach which is affecting my playing!If any one out there can help, email me at CrustyJelloToes@hotmail.com! By the way...GREAT ARTICLE! I will be sure to watch out for it!
*muahz*
|
|
Former DI hockey player
11-06-2001 10:26 am
|
Report this post
|
|
Unfortunately, sometimes the opposites can happen. I came into playing at 148 (probably the first time I stepped on a scale in years). I wasn't the quickest runner or the strongest person, but I sooned vouched to be. After morning practices~I would go out for an evening run and an evening lift. When my parents saw me 4 months later, they were shocked and upset. I had lost almost 25 pounds. Neither of my coaches noticed nor any or my teammates (neither had I for that matter). I was unhealthy, withdrawn and I had stopped caring about anything except what I looked like out on the field. I quit the next year, because I finally realized that in order to succeed in anything, I need to put myself first, and not what everyone thought.
|
|
Ali
11-23-2001 6:46 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I only just got done with my first year of field hockey in 7th grade. I most say I only liked it more and more as the season went on. I'm touched about what you say, and I'll keep in mine as I grow older.
|
|
Gina P.
01-07-2002 6:03 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Hi, that was a great article. I have a couple friends with body image problems and we talked about this, and are really making progress. Aside from body image, what are your feelings on the pill Xenadrine? and other pills like it? I find they help my performance, but everyone tells me they are bad for me? Im not addicted or dependent on them, they just help, and i take them only during the season.
|
|
|
|
bell
01-28-2002 3:39 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I think your article is great!! its just what many of us have to go through!! well done.
|
|
|
|
Katie HUBBARD
03-21-2002 2:08 am
|
Report this post
|
where i could find more info
For my school Sport class we have to do an assignment on community health and I have choosen Aneroxia Athletica. I was just wondering where I could find more information or links or even phone numbers.
Any
|
|
Helen Seavill
03-28-2002 9:32 am
|
Report this post
|
Although i have never been to america; as i myself am english, i can asure both Jessica and everyone else with posted veiws - that many feild hockey players feel exactly the same! I am just 17 and would say a small build and have been playing hockey since i was about 7. I also play left midfeild at a high level in England. It never occured to me that hockey would changed my body image - but only in the last two seasons have i realised the tightness of jeans around my thighs and also my "bulging biceps". I always wonder if i didn't play, would i look the same.
Although i owuld love to have some breathing space around the thigh and arms - i love my sport and i wouldn't change it for the world!
|
|
Stacey
03-28-2002 2:30 pm
|
Report this post
|
Track and Field Athlete
I am glad i came across this article. I am a senior in college and i am finishing up my fourth and last outdoor season in track and field. I to am proud of being strong. As a short sprinter, i can hold my own with the guys. I can bench 155 and squat 410. I too use to take pride in these numbers, however i am only 5'7" and weigh 145. i hate my body. i want to be lean and skinny with muscle, but can not achieve it. i feel kinda relieved i am not the only one out there that feels this way. I am still desperate to lose weight though. Right now i am taking diet pills hoping to lean down before competing again outdoors. Any suggestions?
|
|
Kimmie
04-02-2002 9:48 am
|
Report this post
|
|
I know exactly how you feel. I am now almost at the end of my first spring with a division 1 field hockey program and have already gained over 15 pounds and weigh 153 pds. How do I over come this obsession to lose the weight I have gained. Can you help me?? My email address is princess102002@yahoo.com.
|
|
Milly
05-21-2002 7:59 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I can relate to what she has gone through as i did much the same thing in my sport, rowing. You get sucked in to a world where nothing else matters but image. It sucks. Well done to her for managing to escape the warp. Not everyone does.
|
|
Melisa
05-30-2002 7:21 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
This article was wonderful. I went through the same problems in college and still, am having problems dealing with my weight today. How do you overcome these feelings of being fat or too thick? I have tried everything. I have gone to extreme measures to acheive the body that I feel is "perfect" and I am still not happy. I would love advice from anyone. =)
|
|
High school player
06-21-2002 3:39 pm
|
Report this post
|
I'm just getting over it
I can completely relate to this article in some aspects. Except it was my coach who drove me to bulemia, leading me to believe I wasn't a good runner, I thought I wasn't because I was overweight. He drove me to this obsession with running and lifting everyday,even after a game or practice, then I began just throing up whatever i ate. Once the season ended, I gave up certain foods and continued running and lifting every day. When our indoor league started, I wasn't the same player i was in the fall, my strength was shot, I was 117lbs of nothing. I too fell into a depression, staying home, exercising after EVERY meal. Just this past week I realized I needed to be the same strong player I was last year. I wasn't a "beast" I didn't have trouble fitting into clothes, I was me, the me I have always been, weight never bothered me, and I was happy. Well I'm going back to that. And thanks to this article I realize how common in it is.
|
|
Lee
06-25-2002 7:40 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Terrific article!!! Im a feild hokcey player. I have struggled with my body image also but strangly enough it is the opposite. it might sound stupid but i cant put weight on. I have battled for years to put on the pounds and have not been able to do so. Listening to people crtising the skinny, caused me to think there must be something wrong with me. I hear that it is unhealthy to be skinny and as a teenager i beleived that this was targeted at me. As a junior i was a strong, fast and skillfull player, but people would always comment on the fact that i was thin. This made me look at myself different. At the time i was an all rounded athlete, however i was so obsessed with how i looked that i decided to stop all sport, because i beleived this would put on weight. Four years later i weigh exactly the same a mere 47 kilos at 5'6. Ive started playing hockey again and i still wish i could put on the weight, but thats me. I am meant to be thin. i think that no matter what we look like we will always look for a better way to look. If you a roubust... thats who who are if you are healthy and fit i see nothing wrong with that. I sympathise with all of you girls who have shared there battles with body image and hockey but trust be BEING THIN AINT THAT GREAT even if thats the way that you are meant to be. Like being labled the "BEAST", we are also given names that affect our self esteem. I think that this highlights a common problem with society, the problem is how do we change this. Eating disorders are so common... and they are not as simple as bulemia and anorexia, there are many other ones that are less common but affect a large amount of people. Stop starving yourselves it is not worth lossing your happiness, your strength and your self respect.
|
|
Ms V
06-26-2002 10:00 pm
|
Report this post
|
Yes, an excellent article, but the story is sadly repeated all over the world. (G'Day Nik!)
Whilst the problem is an overall societal problem, one must ask how to actually change this. After being a top athlete in Aust, I almost attended a college on a hockey scholarship. I toured a few colleges and study their programes. I found that they were FAR to reliant on bulking their athletes up with muscle. (I should know, us Aussies were No1 in the world and did not have such bulked training ideas) Their programing did not seem to be very sport specific or even player specific, as their was no question as to what the correct strength/speed/agility was going to be best for that individual. It's no good if you bulk a goalie up, making them strong, yet taking away from their flexibility, and how does the new bulk truly affect their reaction times. There seems to me a lot of trainers (bulk and weight) in the system, and not enough sport scientists.
Steve, I hope your approach to the team you coach is much more well rounded. I'm sure you take more of an interest in your members, than it sounds to have been in the past. Perhaps the college, and more specifically the hockey community in the US will realise that this is not the best way to the top. I would love the US team to involve themselves in the Aust setup whent hey head over hear for the World Cup, perhaps some plans can be out into place for us to share our info!?
|
|
Abby
08-05-2002 8:44 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Jesiica I really know how you feel. I am on;y 14 and have had this problem often and i really wanted you to know that this artical stopped me from makeing a hudge mistake. Like you I weigh 148 almost 150 and I am 5"6" I reallt thought I was fat to but like your friends and family I was told the same exact thing. I am currently in the 8th grade and am doing fh camp now. I really think that your artical could and will help many teens with there problems with disorders.Iknow you helped me! Thanks lots!!! ~Abby~ my e-mail Faith@post.bwkip.com
|
|
kelsey
08-14-2002 12:19 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Jess, great article. The numerous responses merely emphasize the importance (and prevalence) of this topic. As a D1 FH player, and 4 sport athlete in highschool, I too have dealt with all of these problems - from anorexia (in seventh grade) to bulimia in highschool - my soccer coach told me i needed to be faster, so i thought that meant skinnier. I was in great shape and naturally have a muscular body, so it was very hard to lose weight... which lead to the eating disorder which has plagued me for the past 8 years. I think coaches, parents, friends, and players all need to be aware of these issues and to NOT inforce the "skinnier is better" mentality. And to watch for signs of eating disorders in young girls - to try and stop them before they start - because it becomes a lifelong battle, that is hard to beat. Muscular physiques are great - and need to be looked upon as such. It's not worth starving yourself or taking pills or laxatives to achieve the ultimately "unattainable" body.
|
|
Andrew
11-14-2002 10:39 am
|
Report this post
|
|
Great article. Just being able to write something so innate speaks volumes of the ground you made on such a personal battle. Good for you.
|
|
Fieldgirl
12-28-2002 12:48 am
|
Report this post
|
I enjoyed your article, this is sometihng that many girls truggle with and i am too...i gained 12 pounds this last season and felt/feel horrible...but one thing that would help is knowing how you got to the mindset you are at now...besides graduating..what did you have to do?
Thank you
|
|
Kara
02-26-2003 1:48 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I have really enjoyed your article. I am a swimmer in college and struggle with the same thing. I am very musculure but I also feel the pressure to be a tiny little water bug in the water. I am so happy to see that someone has spoken out on this topic. It is one that is hidden in sports and needs to be discussed a lot more. Thanks so much for writing this!!!
|
|
Melissa
06-25-2003 10:29 am
|
Report this post
|
|
Thank you for sharing you're story, and I being only a high school athlete can very much relate to it. Any competitive athlete most likely can, body image is hard to maintain when you have other things to stay on top of also. Once again, thank you for sharing you're story and I'm glad to hear you're finally happy with yourself :)
|
|
Jossy99
08-08-2003 11:11 am
|
Report this post
|
|
i think hockey players shouldnt be skinny i think they should be quite a big build but not huge but a fine build hope u guys understand me :confused:
|
|
Kate
03-03-2004 8:36 am
|
Report this post
|
I too played hockey in college. I'm not playing for financial reasons but I too experienced the body image problem. After my first season in DI athletics we were "weighed out" before we left for Christmas break, to see the results formt he season and basically because we knew when we got back from break we would get it again. Then we would probably be penalized too for the weight we may have gained. Where as my teammates gained weight over break... I was mortified at my "weigh out". My coach told me I had gained 1 pound. Now 1 pound is not bad but it was made out to be a huge deal! I came back from break and had lost 20 pounds in 3 weeks. I recognized that i had no control over my weight and over anything.
Thank you for you're story! Sometimes when I walk into a clothing store I felt alone having to wear a 4 in the waist but a 11 in the thighs!
|
|
F-DI PLAYER
03-04-2004 4:59 am
|
Report this post
|
I think the reason why this article has recieved so many responses is because this sort of problem is rampent in women's athletics. I think the problem is more specific to woman in athletics than it is to general body image issues in our society.
In order for a division one athlete to be competitive she has to be fit. For many this comes naturally but for others it is not as natural. Different individuals have different body types and structures that will make it harder or easier to conform to the type of physical fitness necessary to compete.
Many coaches and trainers maintain that diet and exercise have everything to do with body type and physical fitness.
There should be a greater emphasis on skill, awareness and talent from our coaches in this country.
I think that when coaches are unable to enlighten her players in these areas, conditioning and physical fitness are emphasized. This is bad for the individual and the game as it stands in the US.
I think the role that coaches play in athletic anorexia should be further exlored. Because the lines are blurry and the player may often recieve praise for her weight loss it is important for the coach herself to have a healthy grasp on the unique balance that a female athlete has to maintain.
|
|
Taz
04-21-2004 10:01 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
My best friend was also called "The Beast" ! HAHAHA
|
|
|
|
mad dee
05-06-2004 2:33 pm
|
Report this post
|
plz put me on the boared
well my names demi iam starting a hockey team beacuse i pure liked it in school so just asking for tips and advisefor me plz email me
demixyz2004@hotmail.com
thanks that will be nice if u do and who in the house wants to play it proftionlly just tell me cause iam just a begginer !!!!!! and hi to every1 who nos me loves ya all !!!! :@}
|
|
Nevogal
05-10-2004 7:36 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I understand where you are coming from on the whole body image thing, its really sad that people become so overly concerned with it. I played field hockey in high school for 2 yrs and this year i would of been on varsity except I developed anorexia and was hospitalized all becuase i was unhappy with my image...i was competiting and competiting with myself and was never happy(tho its strange because i knew i was too thin) Now ive missed out on a whole year of playing..Im really glad u didnt become too sicka nd that u shared ur story with others
|
|
Amanda
06-23-2004 9:31 am
|
Report this post
|
|
I have felt like that for a long time and never realized that other people do to! I have always thought that girls in hockey should be thin but still cut,and still be weighing 100 lbs. Now I know that other girls have tht same thing going through there heads! Thank you for sharing your story with me!
|
|
Stacey
07-13-2004 10:51 am
|
Report this post
|
|
I play field hockey and I am over weight and it is not because of my muscles. I love the game and even though I am not in the best shape I have noticed that my love for the sport pushes me harder than most. I know that there will be a struggle with playing if I do not begin to lose some weight but for me I want to look strong. When I play my sports and I am doing a good job I love the feeling and when I look at the muscle my legs gain during the season it makes me proud and makes me feel powerful. Maybe I am different then most but I dont feel that your size has to do with sports and to me I think looking strong is beautiful!
|
|
incoming freshman
07-24-2004 8:12 pm
|
Report this post
|
As I am about to enter my freshmen year of college i have also been watching what I eat, yet while still lifting I have found that I will never be extremely skinny until I have completed my colliegate career.... yet I have learned to deal because I would rather be healthy and an competitive athlete then worried about being able to pose on the cover of a fashion magazine
Thanks again for sharing I am glad that I am not the only one.
|
|
fh04
07-27-2004 8:24 am
|
Report this post
|
|
Your article really moved me. I play field hockey and have friends with eating disorders and I know how hard things like that are to manage. It shows how strong of a person you are to over come such a thing and I wish you the best in your future!
|
|
Jossy99
07-29-2004 8:50 am
|
Report this post
|
i think anyone should be able to play hockey
any size
|
|
field_hockey_girl
08-02-2004 9:18 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I am a high school field hockey player and I'm already feeling a lot of the preasures of my appearance. My coach wants me to be stronger and bulkier and I want to be thinner and a prettier "girly-girl". Because I read your struggles I realized I'm not entirely alone with the way I feel. I think I can find a nice medium between the two extremes and still feel very comfortable with myself. I think you are incredible brave by being able to voice your struggles like this, and I'm glad it worked out for you in the end. I hope I can be as strong in my future battles.
|
|
Sarah From Canada
09-14-2004 6:49 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
Thats totaly true i love that u can just go out and say that.... I was 150 before field hockey started and i have lost 20 pounds since and its been like not even 2 months I"m just under 130... it seems like i cant eat i dunno what to do about it it seems like once i exercize I"m just not hungery ever....
|
|
ziggy
10-11-2004 3:38 am
|
Report this post
|
how to grow taller
i'm near enough 5' 9'' and want to grow taller. i think proteins are the only way.i also play rugby and my mates take the mick even though iam strong i don't have the height over the oppostion. help me send any ideas to ziggyz707@hotmail.com
|
|
Floris
02-03-2005 9:20 am
|
Report this post
|
Girls, Look at how many of you have replied to this article.
It is sad how many of you feel repressed by societies asthetic pressures.
Please look at the things that are good in your life and concentrate on the acheivable. As you all seem to be sports women, you will be stonger and more powerful than your none sporting friends. This is good, you look healthier and therefore more attractive. You will feel fitter and have a better sense of well being. So what if the girl's on the cover of magzines don't look the same as you, they spend half the time in the bathroom anyway.
|
|
hockeyfairy
02-10-2005 6:18 am
|
Report this post
|
|
what a great article. im 18 years old and play fairly high level hockey, and whilst i am one of the smallest on my team, i am alot bigger than many of my friends. after stepping my training up a gear this season, i have gained weight in muscle and looking at the scale isnt the nicest of things. articles like this should b used to prove to young girls that how you look isnt everything and you can just be recognised for your sport not how small you are
|
|
still fighting
06-02-2005 7:34 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
I hear every word you are saying... i also played in college...it started for me toward the beginning of my senior year and ended up very bad when i was about a year out of college. I suffered really bad with anorexia... it's a hard world we live in but it's so nice to hear that you are happy, i'm still struggling with trying to get there!
|
|
fh11stxtrx
06-04-2005 3:14 pm
|
Report this post
|
American Ideals
This article and the posts really caught me. Before I became an international D-1 college player, my sister and I would watch tv shows and always marvel at the emphasis put on image and looking thin in the U.S. Then I got here for school, moving into my 3rd yr and understand a little better. When I got here I was 120lbs at 5'4.Dealing with injury and unable to do cardio, lifting weight and eating ensured that I put on 20lbs. I was also told its not just fat its muscle. Clothes didn't fit and I got really depressed. I tried changing my diet but my good friend saw it and called it my starvation diet. It didn't help with my coach talking to us about losing weight all the time, throwing our BFI in our faces or my friends talking about me having 'junk in the trunk'. Never had I been in an atmosphere where young women talked about hating their body so much or wanting to be thin. I had succomed to the pressure. And we as athletes were supposedly the example of healthy living. We weren't and we still aren't. Were are still trying to fit into someone's image of what healthy and beautiful looks like. I blame the media and I blame coaches. In the US, good skill is secondary to who can run a 5 minute mile or lift the most weight. There should be a balance. Coaches and trainers need to reinforce healthy eating and training habits while making athletes feel comfortable with the changes they will experience in their bodies playing at the D-1 level. My first year was hell but I am comfortable now knowing that the American ideals of a perfect body doesn't have to be my prison. So to anyone who may find themselves in this situation, don't succumb to the pressure, see a nutrionist, live healthy and play healthy.
|
|
D1 FH Player in NY
06-04-2005 3:37 pm
|
Report this post
|
the influence of the coach
When you have a coach that is always asking you for your weight, testing your body fat, surprising you with random strength tests, spitting demeaning comments at you if you don't look like the perfect slender athlete, it's really tough to figure out what's best for yourself.
Are you supposed to focus on being slender... or are you to keep piling on the weights??
On my team, one of the strongest, fittest & fastest girls on the team is now on a bout to lose weight and tighten her figure because my coach has commented on her size on numerous occasions...
Sometimes I think that coaches can be down-right evil.
Coaches do not always know what is best for us... We must be careful and selective when dealing with advice from anyone (except maybe our doctors), esp. if it serves to weaken our self-image.
I'm entering my third year of D-1 field hockey and am preparing myself mentally for another year of physical scrutiny... good luck to all others who must endure this with me.
|
|
jen*
06-14-2005 10:26 am
|
Report this post
|
|
i agree i feel players r constantly plagued bout their weight and i think it is appaling. if u have the skill and have proved that u have the ability to take part in a full game or a tournament which many ppl have proved then y shld their weight remain an issue. coaches at times need to get in touch with reality.
|
|
center link-fink
06-24-2005 2:42 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
This article is so very inspiring. i am not as old as the rest of you women, but i am unhappy with the way i appear. I play 2 sports hockey and soccer. i love them both dearly. I have very muscular legs, a thin face, flabby arms, and a chunky midsection. i beleive it was created by depression. My first name is really wierd and people have problems with it. that along with a lot of other things made me feel depressed. When i am depressed, i eat, the wrong things, especially. I just wish i could run short sprints like the other girls. i am an awesome long distance runner. i can run the mile in a little under 7 minutes. pretty good for my age(14). I don't want to thin out because of peer pressure. i personally could care less. i think it would improve my game. thanks, this helped a lot.
|
|
Gettin Back
07-09-2005 2:43 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
yeah.. im starting to feel the same way. i wus taken out of everything ((was paralized fer 2 months)) nd this past summer was FINALLY able to train again. i was on this permanet high -- no matter how much my pain is physical from my dystrophy. i looked in the mirror, and thought "omigod im gettin ssoo chuby". then realized i wus gettin bulky from my training from field hockey. im usually about 100 lbs.. sometimes 95. im scared to look at the scale now.. nd unfortenetly, i havent figure out how to stop this obsession of wanting to be/look fit, nd still be my 95 lb. self..
|
|
K8
08-14-2005 8:37 pm
|
Report this post
|
|
This article is a definate eye opener. I will be showing the to high school team I coach. Alot of my girls have body image problems which leads them to eatting disorders unfortunately. I hope that they will learn from what you have gone through and know that there are alternatives and that they are not alone with feeling insecure about their bodies.
|
|
TOTC
09-08-2005 10:26 am
|
Report this post
|
K8 (or Kate), thanks for giving this to your players.
Here's the weird thing about the whole situation. Field hockey is a game where The Ball Does The Work. Not the players!
If you have a good game plan and players who can throw and catch, your players can be armchair athletes and kick the pants off of the teams with 11 human greyhounds.
One story: in Atlanta, a club team from Holland was to play the American U-21 women about a decade ago. The Dutch were having a good old time before the game, enjoying a cig and a libation or two, while the U-21 women were putting themselves through athletic drills.
The Dutch team won.
|
|
renee
09-14-2005 9:59 pm
|
Report this post
|
more honest stories
How can I get more honest stories like this one?
reneejay@email.com
|
|